Κρατύλος

Lines

383 – 384 384 – 385 385 – 385 385 – 386 386 – 387 387 – 388 388 – 388 388 – 389 389 – 390 390 – 391 391 – 391 392 – 392 392 – 393 393 – 393 394 – 394 394 – 395 395 – 395 396 – 396 396 – 397 397 – 398 398 – 398 398 – 399 399 – 399 399 – 400 400 – 401 401 – 402 402 – 402 403 – 403 403 – 404 404 – 405 405 – 405 406 – 406 406 – 407 407 – 408 408 – 409 409 – 409 410 – 410 410 – 411 411 – 411 412 – 412 413 – 413 413 – 414 414 – 414 415 – 415 416 – 416 416 – 417 417 – 418 418 – 418 419 – 419 419 – 419 420 – 420 420 – 421 421 – 422 422 – 422 423 – 423 423 – 424 424 – 424 425 – 425 426 – 426 426 – 426 427 – 427 427 – 428 428 – 429 429 – 430 430 – 430 430 – 431 431 – 432 432 – 432 432 – 433 433 – 434 434 – 434 434 – 435 435 – 436 436 – 437 437 – 437 438 – 438 438 – 439 439 – 440 440 – 440 440 – 440

İngilizce Yunanca

425 Socrates. No, not we; I said that too hastily. For the ancients gave language its existing composite character; and we, if we are to examine all these matters with scientific ability, must take it to pieces as they put it together and see whether the words, both the earliest and the later, are given systematically or not; for if they are strung together at haphazard, it is a poor, unmethodical performance, my dear Hermogenes.

425 Hermogenes. By Zeus, Socrates, may be it is.

425 Socrates. Well, do you believe you could take them to pieces in that way? I do not believe I could.

425 Hermogenes. Then I am sure I could not.

425 Socrates. Shall we give up then? Or shall we do the best we can and try to see if we are able to understand even a little about them, and, just as we said to the gods a while ago that we knew nothing about the truth but were guessing at human opinion about them, so now, before we proceed, shall we say to ourselves that if anyone, whether we or someone else, is to make any analysis of names, he will have to analyze them in the way we have described, and we shall have to study them, as the saying is, with all our might? Do you agree, or not?

425 Hermogenes. Yes, I agree most heartily.

425 Socrates. It will, I imagine, seem ridiculous that things are made manifest through imitation in letters and syllables; nevertheless it cannot be otherwise. For there is no better theory upon which we can base the truth of the earliest names, unless you think we had better follow the example of the tragic poets, who, when they are in a dilemma, have recourse to the introduction of gods on machines. So we may get out of trouble by saying that the gods gave the earliest names, and therefore they are right. Is that the best theory for us? Or perhaps this one, that we got the earliest names from some foreign folk and the foreigners are more ancient than we are? Or that it is impossible to investigate them because of their antiquity, as is also the case with the foreign words?

← Previous 58 / 80 Next →

Şifre Yenileme