Kitap 5
4
These are all things whose nature remains the same in transposition, but whose shape does not; e.g. wax or a coat. They are described as both whole and all; for they have both characteristics. Water, however, and all liquids, and number, are described as all; we do not speak of a whole number or whole water except by an extension of meaning. Things are described as all in the plural qua differentiated which are described as all in the singular qua one; all this number, all these units.
1
We do not describe any chance quantity as mutilated; it must have parts, and must be a whole. The number 2 is not mutilated if one of its 1’s is taken away—because the part lost by mutilation is never equal to the remainder—nor in general is any number mutilated; because the essence must persist. If a cup is mutilated, it must still be a cup; but the number is no longer the same.
2
Moreover, not even all things which have dissimilar parts are mutilated; for a number has in a sense dissimilar as well as similar parts—e.g. 2, 3. But in general of things whose position makes no difference, e.g. water or fire, none is mutilated;— to be mutilated, things must be such as have their position according to their essence.
3
Further, they must be continuous; for a musical scale is composed of dissimilar parts, and has position; but it does not become mutilated. Moreover, even things which are wholes are not mutilated by the removal of any of their parts; the parts removed must be neither proper to their essence nor in any chance location. E.g., a cup is not mutilated if a hole is made in it, but only if the handle or some projection is broken;
4
and a man is not mutilated if he loses flesh or his spleen, but if he loses some extremity; and not every extremity, but only such as cannot grow again when completely removed. Hence bald people are not mutilated.
